Aller au contenu
Ludicademy
English
Thème Élan
ClairsSombres
S’inscrire
bac+2 C1 · Expression orale et écrite

Attitude and judgement: giving an opinion without throwing a chair-Master’s Year 1

Express attitude, evaluation and judgement with precise vocabulary, appropriate register and credible argumentation.

≈ 8 min read · level bac+2 C1 · three questions at the end

Version française English version

In brief
  • Expressing attitude means showing your position towards an idea.
  • Evaluation means judging the value, strength or limits of an argument.
  • At C1 level, prefer precise terms such as convincing , problematic , relevant , questionable or well-founded .

When giving an opinion becomes diplomatic art

At C1 level, simply saying I think it is good is no longer enough. It is correct, but rather flat, like a pancake forgotten under a dictionary. To express attitude or judgement, you need nuance: show whether you approve, doubt, criticize, admire or reject an idea without turning the sentence into a noisy courtroom.

Expressing attitude means showing your position towards an idea. Evaluation means judging its value, effectiveness or limitations. Judgement can be positive, negative or nuanced.

The three levels of judgement

A good evaluation does not just say 'good' or 'bad'. It explains why an idea is convincing, problematic, limited or debatable.

Type of judgementUseful expressionExample
Positiveconvincing / valuable / relevantThis is a convincing argument.
Negative</en>problematic / flawed / questionableThis approach is deeply problematic.
Nuancedpartly convincing / relatively limitedThe proposal is partly convincing but difficult to implement.

Avoid judging too quickly. This idea is stupid is clear, but about as subtle as an elephant in a porcelain shop. Prefer This idea seems poorly supported.

Expressing an opinion precisely

Instead of repeating I think, use richer expressions that suit formal contexts better.

ExpressionNuanceExample
It seems to me that...cautious opinionIt seems to me that the argument lacks evidence.
I would argue that...developed opinionI would argue that the policy is necessary.
From my perspective...personal viewpointFrom my perspective, the reform is too ambitious.
One could argue that...distanced opinionOne could argue that the benefits outweigh the risks.

I would argue that is very useful at C1 level: it sounds more academic than I think, without making your opinion arrive in sweatpants.

Evaluating the strength of an argument

An argument can be strong, weak, incomplete or poorly supported. Precise vocabulary lets you criticize the idea without attacking the person who produced it, even if the idea arrived late and without shoes.

ExpressionMeaningExample
a strong argumentsolid argumentThis is a strong argument in favour of reform.
a weak argumentweak argumentThis is a weak argument because it ignores key evidence.
a flawed argumentdefective argumentThe reasoning is flawed.
an unsupported claimclaim without evidenceThe article relies on unsupported claims.
a compelling pointconvincing pointThe author makes a compelling point.

A C1 judgement must be justified. Saying The argument is weak without explaining why is like announcing 'there is a problem' and then running away.

Expressing a positive attitude

To approve of an idea, show its interest, relevance or value. This is more precise than It is good, which is starting to look seriously exhausted.

ExpressionMeaningExample
valuableuseful / importantThis proposal offers valuable insights.
relevantrelevantThe example is highly relevant.
insightfulperceptive / illuminatingThe analysis is particularly insightful.
well-foundedbased on good reasonsThe criticism is well-founded.
persuasiveconvincingThe author’s conclusion is persuasive.

Expressing a critical attitude

Criticizing does not mean crushing the idea with a dictionary. In academic style, criticism should be precise, calm and sometimes accompanied by a tiny inner smile.

ExpressionMeaningExample
questionabledebatableThe conclusion is questionable.
problematicproblematicThis assumption is problematic.
misleadinglikely to create a wrong impressionThe graph may be misleading.
oversimplifiedtoo simpleThe explanation is oversimplified.
biasednot neutralThe report appears biased.

Misleading does not simply mean 'false'. It means that something may lead to a wrong interpretation. It is the difference between a mistake and a mistake that holds your hand.

Nuancing judgement

At C1 level, it is often better to avoid absolute judgements. An idea may be interesting but limited, convincing but incomplete, useful but difficult to apply. In short, life is complicated, and so is grammar.

ExpressionEffectExample
partly convincingpartial agreementThe argument is partly convincing.
not entirely convincingsoft criticismThe explanation is not entirely convincing.
to some extentnuanceTo some extent, the policy could be effective.
relatively limitedcautious limitationThe impact remains relatively limited.
open to debatedebatableThe long-term benefits are open to debate.

Nuance is your academic shield. It prevents you from promising absolute truth with three examples and a graph that looks tired.

Evaluating a solution

When evaluating a solution, discuss its effectiveness, feasibility, limitations and possible consequences.

CriterionExpressionExample
Effectivenesseffective / ineffectiveThe measure may prove effective.
Feasibilityfeasible / unrealisticThe proposal seems unrealistic.
Consequencesbeneficial / harmfulThe reform could have harmful effects.
Limitslimited / insufficientThe response remains insufficient.
Balancebalanced / one-sidedThe article offers a balanced perspective.

Efficient and effective are not identical. Effective means it works. Efficient means it works with little waste. A coffee machine can be effective and still very inefficient if it requires three prayers and a capsule sacrifice.

Making moral or ethical judgements

Some topics require evaluating what is fair, acceptable or morally problematic. Stay precise and avoid grand statements that hit the table like an angry judge’s hammer.

ExpressionMeaningExample
ethically questionableethically debatableThis practice is ethically questionable.
morally unacceptablemorally unacceptableThe decision is morally unacceptable.
socially responsiblesocially responsibleThe company adopted a socially responsible approach.
fair / unfairfair / unfairThe system remains deeply unfair.
legitimate concernvalid concernPrivacy is a legitimate concern.

Expressing surprise, doubt or reservation

Attitude is not limited to positive or negative judgement. You can also show that something is surprising, worrying or requires caution.

ExpressionAttitudeExample
surprisinglysurpriseSurprisingly, the results contradict previous studies.
understandablyunderstandingUnderstandably, many citizens remain sceptical.
unfortunatelyregretUnfortunately, the policy failed to address the issue.
arguablycautious judgementArguably, this is the most serious challenge.
admittedlyconcessionAdmittedly, the proposal has some advantages.

Attitude adverbs are powerful. Clearly, obviously or undoubtedly express strong confidence. Too much confidence may wake the sceptical examiner sleeping in the margins.

Avoiding overly personal judgements

In academic essays, avoid overly subjective reactions such as I love this idea or I hate this policy. They are not wrong, but an essay is not a diary with a bibliography.

Too personalMore academic
I love this idea.This idea is particularly valuable.
I hate this policy.This policy raises serious concerns.
I think this is bad.This appears to be deeply problematic.
This is stupid.This argument is poorly supported.

Scenario: almost civilized debate

ExaminerHow would you evaluate the author’s argument?
StudentIt is partly convincing, but not entirely well-supported.
ExaminerGood nuance.
StudentThank you. I wanted to say it was a mess, but I dressed the sentence properly.
ExaminerThat is academic progress.

Remember
  • Expressing attitude means showing your position towards an idea.
  • Evaluation means judging the value, strength or limits of an argument.
  • At C1 level, prefer precise terms such as convincing, problematic, relevant, questionable or well-founded.
  • Judgements should be nuanced and justified.
  • Good academic style criticizes clearly, but does not throw rhetorical chairs.

Key expressions

Expression Meaning
This is a convincing argumentEvaluating an argument positively
The proposal is partly convincing but difficult to implementGiving a nuanced judgement
The article relies on unsupported claimsCriticizing lack of evidence
The analysis is particularly insightfulExpressing positive evaluation
The conclusion is questionableExpressing critical judgement
The graph may be misleadingEvaluating evidence critically
The long-term benefits are open to debateNuancing a judgement
The proposal seems unrealisticEvaluating feasibility
This practice is ethically questionableMaking an ethical judgement
This policy raises serious concernsExpressing formal criticism

Maintenant, jouez-la

Trois questions pour voir

La règle est lue. Voyons si elle est entrée : trois questions, ici même, sans compte.

3 exercices corrigés d'anglais en bac+2 C1 → sans compte, corrigés à chaque réponse

La règle est lue ; il reste à la faire entrer. Trois minutes suffisent.

Jouer « Le grand livre des citations » → Quiz Express · sans compte

Ou choisissez votre salle :

Une pause entre deux leçons ? 🎪 Le salon de jeux de société → belote, tarot, sudoku…

Toutes les leçons bac+2 C1